After the Assignment: Late Papers and Revisions
by Lee Ann Dickerson
I like this time of year—the days grow noticeably shorter, the fair and the zombies come to town, and school starts. I also like to think outside the syllabus, and in this post, I want to share with you two ideas I’ve experimented with to get some students to write—after the due date and after the grade. These are my late and revision policies for the Fall 2013 semester, my rationale for them both, and some of my experimentation and results.
First, students in my classes are allowed to turn in each of their four major writing assignments beyond the due date until the end of the semester without grade penalty, but only if they compensate for it. My syllabus reads:
In the event of a late submission, the paper must be accompanied by a 500-word essay in proper MLA format explaining the reason for the late submission and an explanation of either:
- How you are a complete victim of circumstance or
- What you could have done to prevent the late submission, and what changes you will make to prevent a re-occurrence.
I first came across the idea in Peter Filene’s The Joy of Teaching, though the original scheme wasn’t his, either. In a slim sentence, Filene reports that this approach was another professor’s idea to discourage late work. I latched onto the idea because I was never completely comfortable with the oft-used though entirely understandable approach of penalizing writing assignments for not being punctual. I know and respect the importance of deadlines, but it always seemed to me that writing and timeliness were two separate skills to be cultivated in many of today’s college freshmen. The extra essay offers a chance to distinguish between the two and evaluate writing on, simply, writing.
When I told one of my teaching mentors of my plans to adopt the approach, she was aghast: “You’re just creating more work for yourself!” But I don’t grade these extra essays. I do not even promise to read them, though I have done so simply because I find them so interesting. In five classes over two semesters, I have received six of these “late essays,” and two were from the same student. Only one such essay appeared to parrot the phrases and adopt the excuses that so often verbally accompany late work. The others, including both from my prolifically tardy student, exhibited serious self-reflection and ownership of the responsibility to manage one’s time well and be prepared for life’s stop lights and detours. I never graded the “late essays” nor responded to them, but I do not believe that I need to be either omnipresent or constantly wielding points in order for real learning to take place. Of the five students who submitted “late essays” to accompany their assignments, four did so only once, and those four ultimately finished the course. I cannot empirically prove that the additional writing significantly altered either character or skill, but this approach is one I will again implement this fall.
Students who turn in papers past the due date forfeit the right to re-write for a better grade, but timely students can take advantage of my revision policy, matured this spring through a little trial and error. My syllabus now reads thus:
In the event of a re-submission, the paper must be accompanied by a 500-word essay in proper MLA format explaining:
- What revisions were made, and
- What was learned from the revision that can be applied to future papers.
Immediately, I discovered a problem with this opportunity similar to that which many instructors who teach revising techniques often encounter: students often lack the ability to identify what should be revised and the experience and knowledge to explain any revisions, especially in 500 words. In the fall semester of 2012, I received only one revised essay, and it was not strong. I realized that in order for my re-submission essay policy to be most effective, I would need to help students by both prompting some necessary changes and providing the framework for discussing them.
Like you, I invest a lot of time and care into my written responses to students in their drafts, comments which historically and lamentably are—at best—skimmed and—at worst—ignored. In an effort to u-turn this trend and continue the discussion with students over their writing, I continued to write declarative statements, but I also began to interrogate: e.g. “Did you mean to put this here?” or “But what about…?” or “Why…?” or “What was your reasoning here?” or “What would happen if…?” Then I waited. In my online class, I also began to add to some of those comments requests for students to email me their answers to my inquiries. Not all students responded, which indicated to me that some were still not spending the time reviewing their writing with the close effort that I was trying to encourage. Over the course of the online spring semester, I received two substantially revised and greatly improved essays.
By the third assignment in my face-to-face classes this spring, I enhanced the approach even further. On the day that I electronically returned their graded research papers, I gave students class time to read my bubbled and in-text e-comments in Word. Then, I asked them to write back. I spoke to a few individually about my comments or details or particular issues, but in this mostly quiet time, all students wrote in a separate document their responses to the queries I had inserted into their work. When they turned these new papers in at the end of class, they had created the beginning of the “re-submission essay” that would qualify their work to be fully re-assessed, again without grade penalty. No students ultimately revised their work for a better grade as a result of my experiment, but the classwork revealed some encouraging analysis of themselves as writers. This fall, I will ask students will respond in writing to each of the four major writing assignments, stoking more of that self-analysis and shortening the trip from draft to draft by encouraging the dialogue between them.
Beginning writing students often breathe a sigh of relief when their papers are finally done and the grades reflect their effort, and with my late and revision policies, I encourage both. If you like either of these approaches and think they may also work for you, adopt and adapt at will. And may your semester—before and after the due dates—be fruitful.